Chapter 23 - Ethan's Birthday
We did not drive to the sailing pier.
That surprised Ethan.
I could tell because he called thirty minutes later.
“You’re not coming?”
“You asked for a day.”
“I know.”
“Do you want us to come?”
A pause.
“No.”
“Okay.”
Another pause.
“Dad too?”
“He is sitting three feet away pretending not to listen.”
Daniel mouthed, I am not.
I ignored him.
Ethan said, “Tell him I’m okay.”
“He heard you.”
Daniel leaned closer.
“Eat something.”
Ethan groaned.
“Dad.”
“I get one dad sentence.”
“You get one text a day. Different contract.”
Daniel smiled despite himself.
Ethan stayed overnight at a small inn near the pier after Laura booked it for him under his own name.
Not hidden.
Not tracked without permission.
He came home the next afternoon.
Vanessa’s letter remained in his backpack.
He did not show anyone for a week.
Then he brought it to my apartment.
“Read it.”
I looked at him.
“Are you sure?”
“Yes.”
“Why me?”
“Because Dad will make a face.”
“I also make faces.”
“Different faces.”
Fair.
The letter was eight pages.
Vanessa’s handwriting was elegant and slanted.
She began with memories.
Ethan’s first fever.
The time he broke a lamp and hid the pieces in a cereal box.
A trip to the Bahamas.
His fear of the air conditioner.
She remembered details he had forgotten.
Then the letter became an argument.
She said Daniel had abandoned them.
She said the criminal trial had been politically influenced.
She said I had exploited Ethan’s confusion.
She said Claire had betrayed the family.
Then, on page seven, she wrote something different.
I know you heard enough to understand I hurt Colin. I still wake up hearing the water. I have spent years insisting that the worst second of my life was not the truest second of my life. Maybe that distinction only matters to me.
I stopped reading.
Ethan watched me.
“Keep going.”
The last page said:
I do not ask you to forgive me. I do ask you not to let them make me into a monster so simple that you have to cut every good memory out of yourself to hate me properly. If you remember me making pancakes, remember it. If you remember me lying, remember that too. I am still your mother even if you decide you never want to see me again. I am sorry that sentence is a burden.
I lowered the letter.
Ethan sat with his knees pulled up on the couch.
“Well?”
“What do you want me to say?”
“I don’t know.”
“Then I don’t want to fill the silence just because it’s uncomfortable.”
He looked at the floor.
“Was it manipulative?”
“Yes.”
His face tightened.
“And honest?”
“Yes.”
He looked at me.
“Both?”
“Both.”
“That’s annoying.”
“Very.”
He took the letter back.
“I hate her.”
“Okay.”
“I miss her.”
“Okay.”
“I don’t want to visit.”
“Okay.”
“I might later.”
“Okay.”
He stared at me.
“You sound like a malfunctioning therapist.”
“I’m not a therapist.”
“Obviously.”
I threw a cushion at him.
He laughed.
His eighteenth birthday arrived on a rainy Saturday.
No beach club.
No foundation ballroom.
No photographers.
Ethan asked for tacos, a chocolate cake from a supermarket, and exactly eight people.
Daniel.
Me.
Laura.
Claire.
Owen, who extended his trip.
Maya Torres.
Paige, the girl from school.
And Chief Rhodes, whom Ethan invited because “every bad party should include one police chief.”
Rhodes said, “I’m not saluting anybody.”
Ethan replied, “Dress code says casual.”
Daniel cooked nothing.
This was intentional.
At dinner, Owen told an embarrassing childhood story about Daniel falling into a koi pond during a wedding.
Daniel said the pond had been poorly marked.
Claire said, “It was a pond.”
Paige laughed too hard because she was nervous.
Ethan pretended not to notice.
I noticed.
I did not say anything.
After cake, Laura handed Ethan a folder containing the trust documents.
“No pressure tonight,” she said. “These are the final versions your independent lawyers prepared.”
Ethan stared at the folder.
“Can I burn them?”
One of the lawyers, who had been invited for ten minutes solely to witness signatures if Ethan chose, said, “Legally, yes, after you sign the receipt acknowledging delivery.”
Everyone laughed.
Ethan decided to place most voting authority with an independent trustee for three years, but kept the right to remove the trustee with court review.
He also directed a portion of distributions into the Mercer scholarship fund.
Daniel asked, “Are you sure?”
Ethan said, “No.”
Then signed.
That made me smile.
Later, Rhodes pulled me aside near the kitchen.
“There’s something you should know.”
I immediately hated his tone.
“What?”
“Vanessa filed an appeal.”
“That is her right.”
“Yes.”
“Is there something unusual?”
“Her appellate lawyer is challenging admission of the Gull Point recorder and part of Colin’s phone recovery chain.”
“Expected.”
Rhodes hesitated.
“What?”
“Merrick is changing his story.”
My stomach tightened.
“How?”
“He now claims the old recorder was planted in the cave after Vanessa’s arrest.”
“By who?”
“He says Adrian and Claire coordinated it.”
“That’s ridiculous.”
“Probably.”
“Probably?”
“He has one detail that concerns prosecutors.”
I stared at him.
“What detail?”
“He correctly described damage on the recorder casing that was not public.”
The party noise faded behind me.
“How would he know that if he never saw it?”
“That is the question.”
I looked toward Claire.
She was laughing at something Owen said.
“Have you asked her?”
“Not yet.”
“Why tell me?”
“Because you will hear soon, and because Claire trusts you.”
I shook my head.
“No.”
Rhodes frowned.
“No what?”
“I am not becoming your unofficial bridge to a witness again.”
He stared at me.
Then nodded.
“Fair.”
“Ask her yourself. With counsel.”
“Fair.”
I walked away before curiosity could make me useful in the wrong way.
That was progress.
It felt terrible.
The next morning, Torres interviewed Claire with her attorney present.
Claire admitted she had seen the Gull Point recorder before police found it.
My stomach dropped when she told me later.
“When?”
“Eight years ago.”
“Where?”
“Room 814.”
Of course.
She explained Vanessa used the recorder to capture private conversations with Hartwell and Merrick. Claire saw it on a table and noticed a crack along one corner after Vanessa threw it during an argument.
That matched Merrick’s secret detail.
“So Merrick could know the damage because he saw it too,” I said.
“Yes.”
“Why didn’t you tell prosecutors?”
“They never asked if I recognized the recorder itself. They asked if I knew about the cave archive. I didn’t.”
“That sounds dangerously technical.”
“I know.”
“Did you intentionally avoid mentioning it?”
Claire hesitated.
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because every new thing I remembered made me look more involved.”
I stared at her.
“That was a terrible decision.”
“Yes.”
“Could it affect Vanessa’s appeal?”
“Yes.”
“Could it affect your plea?”
“Yes.”
She sat down.
“I’m sorry.”
“To me?”
“To everybody.”
“That is too broad to be useful.”
She laughed weakly.
“Right.”
Her attorney disclosed the omission to prosecutors immediately.
Vanessa’s appellate team learned within days.
The press called it a bombshell.
It was not.
It was a problem.
Problems can be serious without exploding.
A hearing was scheduled to determine whether the recorder evidence had been adequately authenticated.
For the first time since the trial, there was a realistic possibility one major piece could be excluded from future proceedings if a retrial ever occurred.
Ethan found out from the news.
He called me furious.
“Does this mean she gets out?”
“No.”
“Are you sure?”
“No.”
He went silent.
“Sorry,” I said. “I know that answer sucks.”
“No. Keep doing that.”
“What?”
“Not lying because you think I need it.”
I sat down at my desk.
“The appeal is about evidence rules. Her conviction was supported by much more than the recorder.”
“So probably no?”
“Probably no.”
“Better.”
The authentication hearing was set for the following month.
On the morning it began, Vanessa entered the courtroom in prison clothing.
She looked at Ethan.
He had decided to attend.
She smiled at him.
He did not smile back.
But he did not look away.
Then Vanessa’s lawyer stood and announced they had located a new witness.
The courtroom shifted.
The judge asked for the name.
The attorney answered, “Owen Vale.”
Every head turned toward Daniel’s brother.
Owen sat three rows behind us.
His face went white.
“I’m not their witness,” he whispered.
His phone buzzed in his hand.
A message from an unknown number.
He showed it to me.
WE HAVE THE REST OF COLIN’S LETTER.
---
(To be continued)
Thank you so much for reading this far.
If you enjoyed this story, be sure to bookmark my website: https://metro.treeiq.biz
May you like
New stories are posted every day, so check back often for the latest updates.
